Reading Notes : Ovid's Metamorphoses Part B

For Part B of Ovid's Metamorphoses, the stories that interested me most were the ones about Narcissus and Pyramus and Thisbe. What attracted me to these in particular was the tragic endings that befell the characters, one out of pure love and one out of vain infatuation. After reading them together, it is hard to not compare the two. In both, I could understand (but not relate) to the intesity of each person's emotions, which ultimately caused everyone's untimely death.

Both stories were not afraid to use the extreme end of the dramatic spectrum to describe the depth of feelings. I like this technique; there is no wishy-washiness and the reader is very clear at where each character stands. Part of this is because the characters take out their emotions on their own bodies, and the consequence is clear. When Narcissus cannot embrace his own appearance, he beats his own chest and bruises his marble-like body. Pyramus, after finding Thisbe's bloody scarf, stabs himself in the side. Both males could not live without what they desired most, Narcissus being himself and Pyramus being Thisbe. What I couldn't quite get on board with was Narcissus being celebrated after his death as a beautiful flower. In his scenario, he personally does not bring much to his table, but his beauty is practically worshipped even after his death. Pyramus and Thisbe's ashes being kept in the same urn gave me a measure of comfort that finally in death, they can be together.

It would be interesting to have some similar comparison between two chapters in the storybook. Two stories with similar intensity of emotions, but different motivations that leave a different impact on the reader. With Narcissus, I realize that it characters need not be only good or evil; while I don't find anyting particularly substantial to him, his death was still tragic as he never hurt other intentionally. These types of ambiguous characters could be useful in illustrating a specific moral or lesson to be learned. One thing is for certain, from all the stories I read in this unit, the stupidity and lust of men is ever present, ever having consequences, and yet men never seem to learn from their mistakes (*cough cough, Jupiter).

Echo and Narcissus by John Waterhouse; source: Wiki

The Metamorphoses, Ovid. Translated by Tony Kline. Web Source.

Comments

Reading Notes : Hans Christian Andersen, Part B

ANOTHER FAVORITE. The Little Mermaid is such a classic, and the original slaps. I guess I am old and beaten down now, but this version is my new favorite. The Disney version will always have a special place in my heart and be a part of my childhood, but his original version is so poetic. It is definitely more my style; it leaves an impression when the heroine doesn't get to live happily ever after, which is okay too! The world Hans Christian Andersen weaves is glorious . I could feel the mermaid's pain, urgency, and suffocating need to love and be loved. This is a story that will never get old, part of it due to how beautifully it is written. One of my favorite parts is when he describes the five older sisters and the things they experienced going to the surface for the first time. The scenes he paints makes me feel like I am experiencing those beautiful landscapes for the first time, too. Often time mermaids are fantasized, and it was interesting seeing it from the other per...

Week 11 Story : Guide to Surviving An Asian Father-in-law

In a house on the other side of the world, there lived a very beautiful girl. She took may suitors as husbands, but one by one they perished by the tricks of her father. Her father was very cruel and possessive of her beauty, not believing any man was good enough for her. At last, only one husband remained. His features were light in comparison to her midnight black hair and dark chestnut eyes, but she was determined to help him survive the tests of her father. One evening, the father invited the husband over to his house for dinner, expecting to rid himself of his son-in-law once and for all. "You must absolutely not wear your shoes inside his house." the wife warned. "Although the ground looks calm, you will burn up if your shoes touch the carpet." When the son arrived, he followed the father inside. "There is no need for you to remove your shoes here, I will take no disrespect." the father urged. But the son, aware of his tricks, vehemently insist...

Reading Notes : Heroes, Part A

One thing I really enjoyed so far about this reading is how long the stories are. Instead of individual stories per chapter, each of these takes up about three chapter for one story. I felt like this really helped with character and plot development. Also, unlike the Alaskan stories I read last week, these stories were a bit more realistic, in the sense that they took place (mainly) on earth with real animals and real events in nature. Everyone loves a good hero story, and all of these were untraditional in their own way which made them interesting. One that I particularly liked centered around a bluejay, whose selfish actions were the reason he got sent on a journey to begin with. But upon his return, despite overcoming many obstacles, his life is pretty much the same before. It was interesting how their definition of hero is quite different from those we typically think of. For humans, it means dominating as the top species. For animals, it usually means just surviving. At ti...

Mythology and Folklore

Search This Blog