Skip to main content

Growth Mindset

 Ctrl+Alt+Delete; source: Laura Gibbs

At first glance, Dr. Dweck's philosophy on the growth mindset seems to be a no-nonsense way of improving even the most lackluster students. This was my first encounter with the professor, but much of what she said in her TED Talk seemed like common sense. Encouraging children that failure isn't permenant certainly encourages them to make more attempts at a problem. Incorporating this type of participation in the classroom leads to more equality. The problem of favoritism is something I observed a lot in grade school; the brighter children are set apart at an early age and continue distancing themselves from their peers until their intelligence seems exponentially higher. 

I don't believe that the growth mindset is as universal as Dr. Dweck explains it, but traits of it can help student excel in specific subjects. I think the strongest tool a student can have is genuine interest in the subject they want to pursue. The growth mindest, when applied to this interest, can help fuel it and keep students motivated when they are struggling. People may not have fixed intelligence, but on some extent, they develop a fixed interest in other areas as they grow into young adults. For example, a business major required to take a basic chemistry course would not feel motivated to do well in the class, since it doesn't benefit him or her at all. In this scenario, the growth mindset should still work in theory, but the lack of motivation nulifies it. 

Applying the growth mindset to a whole classroom, much less a whole school, comes with its own practical challenges. Many of the schools that need it most have a smaller teacher to student ratio than other effluent neighborhoods, and at the end of the day, teachers simply do not have as much time to invest individually in each student. One thought that kept popping in my head while listening to the TED Talk was how the growth mindset doesn't take a holistic approach on students. This is a term and concern Dr. Wood brought up in his KPBS interview. The growth mindset ignores the other factors that might affect a child's ability to learn in favor of the simpler explanation that any student can have high level of achievements by practicing "yet". Motivation is just one aspect of learning, but so is concentration, patience, problem-solving ability, creative thinking, etc. The effectiveness of growth mindset depends on how it works in conjunction with these traits.  

 Diversity; source: Laura Gibbs


Comments

  1. Hi Moriah!
    I also did this growth mindset challenge so it was interesting reading your thoughts about it. I thought you made a really great point when you wrote that although most adults might not have a fixed mindset, they still have fixed interests. I definitely agree that it is much easier to learn and succeed in subjects/tasks that I'm interested in, and much harder in areas that I just do not find interesting. I also loved the image you found at the top of your blog post!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Reading Notes : Hans Christian Andersen, Part B

ANOTHER FAVORITE. The Little Mermaid is such a classic, and the original slaps. I guess I am old and beaten down now, but this version is my new favorite. The Disney version will always have a special place in my heart and be a part of my childhood, but his original version is so poetic. It is definitely more my style; it leaves an impression when the heroine doesn't get to live happily ever after, which is okay too! The world Hans Christian Andersen weaves is glorious . I could feel the mermaid's pain, urgency, and suffocating need to love and be loved. This is a story that will never get old, part of it due to how beautifully it is written. One of my favorite parts is when he describes the five older sisters and the things they experienced going to the surface for the first time. The scenes he paints makes me feel like I am experiencing those beautiful landscapes for the first time, too. Often time mermaids are fantasized, and it was interesting seeing it from the other per...

Reading Notes : Heroes, Part A

One thing I really enjoyed so far about this reading is how long the stories are. Instead of individual stories per chapter, each of these takes up about three chapter for one story. I felt like this really helped with character and plot development. Also, unlike the Alaskan stories I read last week, these stories were a bit more realistic, in the sense that they took place (mainly) on earth with real animals and real events in nature. Everyone loves a good hero story, and all of these were untraditional in their own way which made them interesting. One that I particularly liked centered around a bluejay, whose selfish actions were the reason he got sent on a journey to begin with. But upon his return, despite overcoming many obstacles, his life is pretty much the same before. It was interesting how their definition of hero is quite different from those we typically think of. For humans, it means dominating as the top species. For animals, it usually means just surviving.  At ti...

Reading Notes : Hans Christian Andersen, Part A

I was able to revisit some of my favorite stories from my childhood with this reading. The work of Hans Christian Andersen is so iconic and touching even now. It is really different reading these stories as an adult than as a child; what I took literally before is now so symbolic. I hadn't read the story of the little tin soldier in so long, and with it came a flood of memories. One thing I really love about his writings is how visual they are. For kids, it helps immerse them in the world he is trying to make and really experience the story with the character. For adults, there is something kind of sad and wistful about it. His creativity brings the situations to life in a very enjoyable way. One way he does this is through the flow of the story; it read extremely well and is easy to follow. The narrative is super smooth and beautiful to read, which is a big plus. There is nothing 'hard' or difficult to read about it, and it isn't tedious or repetitive either. Every s...